Can You Use Bathtub Tape Instead of Caulking? (Compared)

When it comes to sealing a bathtub and ensuring it’s set into position, you are going to come across different solutions.

Most people will assume the only way to go is caulking. Yes, caulking is a recommended choice for bathtubs but what about other solutions such as tape?

Can you use bathtub tape instead of caulking?

Bathtub tape is just as effective as caulking when done right. It offers a comprehensive, long-lasting seal that’s easy to set up, efficient, and safe.

If you are comparing bathtub tape to caulking then you are going to end up with a choice that’s versatile and valuable. When looking at what works best for you, it’s recommended to consider the layout of the bathtub.

In some bathrooms, it’s easier to use caulking due to accessibility in the “hard to reach” areas around the bathtub.

If it is fully accessible, you will want to use what works best for you. This includes bathtub tape if that is the direction you wish to go in.

This guide will determine whether it’s smart to use bathtub tape instead of caulking.

Best Bathtub Tape (EDITOR’S CHOICE)

2 Pack Tape Caulk Strip, PVC Self Adhesive Caulking Sealing...
  • 【Flexible Trim Caulk Strips】An easy to use replacement for molding, caulk, and more to provide a maintenance-free barrier...
  • 【Sealed Impermeable and Foldable】Zcintert’s soft caulk tape with linear crease design in the middle, which can be...
  • 【Easy to Trim and Install】Simply peel and press Self Adhesive Caulk Strip to the surface in minutes. It's quick, no mess,...

Last update on 2022-05-23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What Is A Bathtub Tape?

Bathtub tape is a self-adhesive material used for all types of sealing. It can be used for bathtubs, sinks, walls, and/or other fixtures. The tape is robust, versatile, and works well as soon as it is set up along the edges of the bathtub.

What Is Caulking?

Caulking refers to a waterproof sealant that is used to seal different fixtures including bathtubs. It is easy to apply, offers a comprehensive seal, and works well in all environments.

Comparing Bathtub Tape And Caulking

1. Speed

The idea of using a caulk strip along the edges of a bathtub is appealing.

This is why the peel and stick bathtub tape is enticing. You are going to want to consider the speed of each option before deciding which direction to go in.

For the most part, both are easy to apply.

If you use a caulking tool to apply the sealant, it will go ahead as quickly as you want. While bathtub tape is also easy to set up and is not going to take a lot of time.

In this regard, both are a tie but it is much easier to adjust the bathtub tape when you make a mistake. The same is not true with caulking.

bathtub tape instead of caulking

2. Consistency

The consistency of the finish is a real concern with caulking.

When comparing caulking to bathtub tape, you will want to ensure the finish is seamless. This is easier said than done with caulk.

It is not going to be consistent unless you are using a specialized tool. It requires a more delicate and precise approach, which is not required for bathtub tape.

For beginners, the tape often works better.

3. Safety

If you are thinking about safety, both options will get the job done.

Bathtub tape tends to be a little safer as it is not going to spill over to surrounding elements in the bathroom.

This does not apply to the tape.

You are going to get a good seal and it will look great too. This is why a lot of people don’t mind using bathtub tape when sealing a bathtub.

It does its job well.

bathtub tape instead of caulking

4. Durability

A common requirement you are going to have to consider will be durability. If either option is unstable, this becomes difficult to back.

For the most part, both are reliable and will age gracefully while providing a strong seal.

However, bathtub tape tends to be less durable. It is not going to have a well-engrained hold as traditional caulking does.

This is due to how deep the caulk goes while holding the seal in place. This does not apply to bathtub tape even though it is effective at what it does.

You will have to account for this when installing bathtub tape in the bathroom or going down the caulking route.

Final Thoughts

Can you use bathtub tape instead of caulking?

You can use bathtub tape instead of caulking. This peel-and-stick solution is effective, fast, and works well in places that require a seamless finish.

It’s best to look at what works for you when deciding between the two materials. Whether it’s caulking or bathtub tape, the most important aspect is the process itself.

You have to be meticulous during the sealing phase. If you take your time, you are going to see much better results and it will lead to a seal that lasts for a long time.

Look at the layout of your bathtub and go from there.

Read More On Bathrooms:

  1. Are Jacuzzi Tubs Out Of Style?
  2. Comparing Clear and White Caulk For Toilets
  3. Comparing Caulking Tool To Squeeze Tube
  4. Why Is The Toilet Caulk Is Turning Brown?
  5. Tips For Filling Void Under Bathtub
  6. Can Small Bathtub Be Comfortable?