Skim Coat Vs New Drywall (Compared)

When you are assessing a part of your room, it’s easy to want to do things as effectively as possible.

This includes choosing the right strategy when working on the drywall.

You do not want a situation where the drywall begins sagging and/or does not look as you want it to. This can happen if you are not taking the time to look into these details carefully.

One option you will want to assess will be choosing between a skim coat vs drywall.

A skim coat will require more patience, demands a good sander, and will have to be balanced for it to look good. In comparison, new drywall is simpler but more expensive and can cause unevenness.

You have to decide what is the best approach for you but most prefer to go with new drywall as it’s easier to set up.

You will not have to worry about prepping the surface as much as you would with a skim coat.

This article is going to help compare a skim coat vs new drywall for those who are still on the fence.

Best Tool For Skim Coating (EDITOR’S CHOICE)

Kraft GG243 14-Inch Squeegee Trowel
  • package dimensions :3.2 cm L x 30.4 cm W x 38.6 cm H
  • Product type :TOOLS
  • country of origin:China

Last update on 2024-07-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Comparing Skim Coat Vs New Drywall

1. Time and Effort

It’s important to begin with the time and effort associated with this process.

For the most part, the skim coating is going to take much longer than a new drywall. This means you are going to be spending more time working on the project and this can become troublesome depending on the room you’re working in.

If it is a main part of the house, this is going to get messy and that is not always easy on you or those inside the house.

In comparison, a new drywall is going to be much easier to set up and is not going to take as long.

This is something you will have to account for and it often comes down to how certain you are about the investment.

2. Balancing

You will want to look at the balancing aspect of setting up new drywall.

Skim coating is not going to have this issue even though it is time-consuming. As long as you are willing to put in the effort, you are going to be fine and it will balance out as you want it to.

However, if you attempt to do the same with new drywall, it can start to sag. This is why you have to be careful about your strategy and what you attempt to do with the new drywall.

Keep tabs on the drywall and make sure it is going to last and will not sag.

3. Affordability

You are going to have a budget in mind for something like this.

The goal here is to set the budget and then begin comparing options. If it is close, you would not mind going with the easier option (i.e. new drywall).

However, it is common for the skim coating to be more affordable and it is more about the effort you’re going to put into the process. If you are willing to put in the time, you will like this option.

If you don’t have a lot of time then getting a new drywall setup is the way to go.

4. Tools

You will also want to keep tabs on the investment that will go into this process.

You will need to make sure the sander that is in place will work well. You cannot move forward with skim coating unless you have prepped the surface for this type of process.

This is only going to happen if you are willing to invest in the right tools.

If you do have a good sander then this becomes a much easier direction to go in. If not, you will have to find one.

This might push you one way or the other.

Final Thoughts

It is essential to look into these details as you begin comparing a skim coat vs new drywall.

Skim coating is known for being time-consuming, more affordable, and will lead to a balanced result once done. In comparison, adding new drywall is faster, simpler, and will cost a bit more than skim coating.

For those on a tight budget, it might be worth spending more time on the project while saving money.

While others will prefer saving time and just getting the new drywall set up as soon as possible.

This is a decision that can only be made when you have taken the time to assess your options and where the drywall will go. In a busy room, new drywall is often the right option.

Read More About Living Rooms:

  1. Is Skim Coating The Right Option?
  2. Top Advice For Painting Floors
  3. How To Manage Painting Engineered Wood
  4. How To Focus On Distance Between Floor And Drywall
  5. Best Methods For Tiling Over Drywall